When Our Comfort Foods Betray Us

Jump to recipe

Comfort food. It is literally named for what it does for us. Are there other things to turn to for comfort? Of course! In fact, there are many! But today, we will only be talking about this one. Isn’t it funny how the words “comfort food” are deciphered differently, depending on who is thinking about it? For some, it’s Mom’s spaghetti. For others it’s Grandma’s chicken soup, or maybe your own apple pie. For me, it’s a long list of items! Some of my favorite comfort foods are homemade macaroni and cheese, baked goods, sourdough bread, tiramisu, chocolate, a few casserole recipes that are full of creamy goodness, and my mom’s tuna sandwiches. Are you sensing a trend? Sugar and carbohydrates, lol…with a partial exception for the tuna…it’s just really good.

But what happens when the comfort food you have always known no longer makes your body feel good? (Or perhaps it never did, but you didn’t realize it before.) For instance, my yummy favorite mac and cheese hurts my family’s stomachs, since it is made with regular pasta and regular flour. But they LOVE mac and cheese! That one is an easy fix. I just use gluten free pasta and gluten free flour when making the cheese sauce, and voila! It’s fixed! But there are other recipes and foods that aren’t quite as easily adjusted. What then? Never fear! I have some ideas for you!

Let’s talk about baked goodies for a moment. Oh how I love each delicious bite. Muffins, cakes, cookies, breads, bars, etc…I could eat them everyday. (Don’t worry, I don’t actually eat them everyday, I merely said I could, haha.) But what about the ingredients in them that are common allergies or irritants for some people? Does that mean there is no hope? Certainly not! There are many ingredient substitutions that can be made to help you navigate around certain foods you can no longer eat, while keeping the flavor and integrity of the goodies! Here are some examples:

Food to replace [Alternative(s)]

You can experiment with your favorite recipes, taking out what you cannot have, and subbing in what you can have. You will be amazed that they will mostly taste the same…or at least similar enough to still hold the coveted title of “comfort food.” Occasionally, the texture will change slightly, or the goodies with be more dense that the original, but those are elements I am willing to deal with if it means my family will be safe in eating them!

For example, I just made adjustments to my favorite pumpkin-cranberry muffin recipe (see link below), so that it is now much lower on the glycemic index, and also has much less fat and cholesterol than it used to! I think they taste really great, and the kids are big fans of the new recipe, too!  I am excited for you all to try it out and let me know what you think! You can substitute at a 1:1 ratio from the list above if you’d like to add anything back in, too.

I know that sometimes it can feel like a really intimidating task to alter a favorite “tried and true” recipe, but I want to encourage you to give it a go, and see how it comes out! Some of your attempts may be flops. That’s ok! I teach my kids that when a recipe flops, we just figure out what went wrong and move on. We also try to come up with ideas of how to use what we made, even if for a different dish altogether. In fact, a recent cookie recipe fail turned out to be a great crumbled ice cream topping at our house! See what I mean? And sometimes (many times, actually), your recipe alterations will be a success, like my pumpkin-cranberry muffins.

Whatever you do, keep on trying! You can have comfort food that is delicious and healthy for your body, too! Find joy in the process of cooking and nourishing yourself and your family. Like in other things, it’s there if you look for it. Have a beautiful day, mamas!

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *